Playing video games can produce potentially fatal arrhythmias in susceptible children, including those not known to be at risk, and war games are a potent trigger, an international case series and systematic review reveals.
Nineteen patients experienced or suspected arrhythmia while playing video games, six went into cardiac arrest, and four died suddenly.
“Now that we’ve confirmed this new phenomenon, we need to ensure that children and teenagers with underlying heart conditions remain safe in all of their activities,” Claire M. Lawley, MBBS, PhD, and Christian Turner, MBBS, both of Sydney Children’s Hospitals Network, Sydney, Australia told theheart.org | Medscape Cardiology.
“Any child or teenager that has a new blackout, faint, collapse, or seizure should be checked out by their local or family doctor, [who] will then determine if further tests are necessary,” they said.
The study was published online today in the journal Heart Rhythm.
“We had encountered a few children in our practice with underlying heart rhythm problems who were having worrying events during electronic gaming,” explained Lawley and Turner. “After contacting some of our close colleagues in our own region, we discovered the phenomenon was not just confined to our own patients. We therefore made a callout for similar experiences to all of our heart rhythm colleagues around the world.”
For the study, electronic gaming was defined as “playing any game that used electronics to create a system with which a player can interact,” including handheld electronic games, console-based electronic games, computer-based games, and stand-alone systems such as electromechanical arcade games.
The team identified 22 patients (18 in international case series and 4 in a systematic review) as having suspected experienced or proven ventricular arrhythmia while playing video games. The patients (19 male, 3 female) were ages 7-16 years.
Nineteen of the 22 patients had a proarrhythmic diagnosis, and seven of those 19 (32%) had the diagnosis established prior to their gaming event. Of those 7 whose diagnosis was established before the gaming event, 6 were prescribed a β-blocker, 2 had an ICD in situ, and 1 had an insertable cardiac monitor. In 12 (55%) patients, the diagnosis was made after the gaming event.
Ten of those 19 patients with a proarrhythmic diagnosis had catecholaminergic polymorphic ventricular tachycardia (CPVT), 4 had long QT syndrome, 2 had undergone cardiac congenital surgery, 2 had idiopathic ventricular fibrillation, and 1 had coronary ischemia after Kawasaki disease.
In 3 patients, including 2 of those who died, the diagnosis is unknown.
Genetic testing results were available for 17 (77%) patients, with potentially relevant genetic variants identified in 14.
Management varied depending on the severity of the presenting episode, local institutional practice, and patient and family preference. Of note, 5 of the 18 survivors had subsequent episodes of arrhythmia during electronic gaming, 4 of whom were on antiarrhythmic medication at the time.
Video game details were known for 13 patients (59%); eight of the 13 (62%) were playing war games.
The authors suggest that adrenergic stimulation plays a role in the pathophysiology of these arrhythmic events.
They note that the “opt-in nature” of the study may have led to an “underestimation of case numbers” and that they did not address events in older video gamers. Information was also not available on potential confounders such as additional medical diagnoses, sleep practices, and use of stimulants.
Nonetheless, they caution that electronic gaming may be encouraged under the false premise that it may represent a safe alternative to higher-risk sports.
“Previously, heart rhythm specialists around the world would need to educate children with particular heart rhythm conditions and their families about safe sporting activity,” Lawley and Turner said. “Now, we will need to educate them about safe electronic gaming activity, as well.”
Greater Awareness Urged
Elizabeth DeWitt, MD, medical director of the surgical electrophysiology program at Boston Children’s Hospital and assistant professor of pediatrics at Harvard Medical School, commented on the study for theheart.org/Medscape Cardiology. “I care for a patient who suffered cardiac arrest while playing an interactive movie/video game that caused significant emotional excitement, who was ultimately diagnosed with CPVT. This event was the first cardiac symptom.
“As the authors point out, this is not something that I have typically counseled patients with known inherited arrhythmia syndromes to be aware of, focusing more on risk with exertion and emotional excitement generally,” she said. “It is important to highlight and to further increase awareness of this topic.
“Unexplained syncope or palpitations during electronic gaming in previously healthy children or those with congenital heart disease should prompt a thorough evaluation to rule out arrhythmia, including detailed history, family history, ECG, and exercise or pharmacologic stress test,” said DeWitt, who was not involved with this study. “Patients with known inherited arrhythmia diagnoses should be counseled about the potential arrhythmic risk associated with electronic gaming and given consideration to pursue alternative recreational activities.”
A multicenter registry could track such cases and prospectively collect more from around the world “to establish whether additional recommendations or approaches to management beyond those described might be important,” she suggests.
While not a common occurrence, this phenomenon is becoming more prevalent, notes study co-investigator Jonathan Skinner, MBChB, MD, also from Sydney Children’s Hospitals Network.
“Having looked after children with heart rhythm problems for more than 25 years, I was staggered to see how widespread this emerging presentation is, and to find that a number of children had even died from it,” he said in a statement. “All of the collaborators are keen to publicize this phenomenon so our colleagues across the globe can recognize it and protect these children and their families.”
Writing in a related editorial, Johnathan Rast, BS, William White, MD, and Daniel Sohinki, MD, MSc, from Augusta University in Georgia, note that “in the modern era, ‘exertion’ should be understood to encompass activities outside of traditional competitive athletics.Appropriate counseling regarding the risks of intense video game play should be targeted toward children with a proarrhythmic cardiac diagnosis and any child with a history of exertional syncope of undetermined etiology.”
“Furthermore,” they say, “any future screening programs aimed at identifying athletes at risk for malignant arrhythmias should encompass athletes being considered for participation in eSports.”
No funding sources were disclosed. The study authors and editorialists report no relevant financial relationships.
Heart Rhythm. Published online October 11, 2022. Abstract, Editorial
Follow Marilynn Larkin on Twitter: @MarilynnL For more from theheart.org | Medscape Cardiology, follow us on Twitter and Facebook.